« TechStars Investor / Demo Day Boulder 2009 | More Questions from the Rally Cafe Interview »
The Best Board Meetings
Over the past 15 years I’ve been to thousands of board meetings. Last week I had four; this week I have two. I’ve spent a lot of time – often during board meetings – thinking about how to make them better and more effective.
Yesterday, Fred Wilson (who was at the Return Path board meeting in Boulder with me) wrote a great post titled Face To Face Board Meetings. Fred and I have been on a number of boards of the years and I strongly agree with his post. To be effective, board meetings need to be (a) in person and (b) there is immense value in a board dinner the night before a board meeting (maybe not every meeting, but at least once a quarter).
While board meetings have a different tempo at different stages of the life of a company, I’ve developed the point of view that the vast majority of the board meeting should be “forward looking.” Ironically (and frustratingly), the general culture of many VC-based boards – especially larger ones – is “backward looking”.
What I mean by this is that most board meetings are 80% status updates, 10% strategy / issues, and 10% administration. I’m fine with the 10% administration, but the 80% / 10% split on status vs. strategy should be reversed. There are plenty of different ways to organize the “strategy” (I’m using “strategy” as shorthand for “forward looking discussion”) and strategy includes a blend of short, medium, and long term issues, as well as plenty of “tactical stuff” (for those that think “strategy” is too specific a word), but I imagine you get the idea.
My favorite board meetings have the following characteristics.
- All board material goes out 48 hours in advance, including a detailed financial package and operating review of the business. This material includes any administrative stuff (draft 409a report, options grants, compensation stuff, audit stuff, prior board meeting minutes.) Everyone reads this in advance – if the materials go out 48 hours in advance there’s no excuse to have not read it.
- There is a dinner the night before that is at least the board and the CEO. Sometimes it includes non-CEO founders; other times it includes various members of the leadership team. This is a casual dinner (e.g. not expensive or full of pomp and circumstance) – a chance for everyone to catch up with each other. If the board meeting is an afternoon meeting, sometimes you can pull off a lunch prior to the meeting that acts as a proxy for the dinner, or a dinner after, although I find the dinner after to be much less helpful.
- The first 30 minutes of the meeting are administrative. Everyone settles down, you go through any formal board business, discuss it, and get it done. Often it takes five minutes (which gives you an extra 25 minutes for the strategy stuff); sometimes it takes the full 30 minutes. I can’t think of a case where it has ever needed to take longer.
- The CEO then puts up one slide summarizing prior period financial performance and asks if anyone has any questions about the board package. This discussion takes however long it takes.
- The CEO then puts up one slide with the issues he’d like to discuss. These are bullet points that are crisp yet detailed enough to know what the issue is. This is then the bulk of the meeting.
Some CEOs are capable of running a 2+ hour discussion off of one slide (I love these guys). Others need slides to prompt them through the setup for each topic (which is fine). Either way, the setup for each topic should be brief (five minutes at most) and the bulk of the activity should be a discussion. The CEO and management team is looking for board feedback, input, advice, and guidance. Ultimately, the CEO has to synthesize this and decide what he wants to do, but by engaging the board in an active discussion, the team will generally get useful input as well as discover where there might be additional domain expertise around the table on the particular issue.
I’ve found that the more time that is spent on #5, the more impactful the meeting is. Obviously, it’s difficult for people on the phone to engage as effectively, which draws them into physically attending the meeting, or not participating.
I’ve got a lot more thoughts on this, but realize I’ve got to get off my ass, get in the shower, and head over to the Boulder Theater for TechStars Investor / Demo Day. More on this another time.









Pingback: feld on directors meetings | techblawg
Pingback: How to Run a Great Board Meeting | Mendelson's Musings
Pingback: Board Meetings « Bold Bio
Pingback: links for 2009-08-10 « lugar do conhecimento
Pingback: peHUB » peHUB First Read
Pingback: Running Effective Board Meetings
Pingback: VC Behavior in Board Meetings
Pingback: Board Meeting Lessons From The Supreme Court
Pingback: Happy Birthday Return Path
Pingback: Why Think When You Can PowerPoint? | Redfin Corporate Blog
Pingback: What are the better things you can do at a private company's directors meetings? - Quora
Pingback: SE Podcast #19 - Blog – Stack Exchange
Pingback: Delicious Bookmarks for September 20th through September 22nd « Lâmôlabs
Pingback: The Human Factors » Reinventing the Board Part III: The Agenda
Pingback: Welcome Jane, from Ubuntu, to ScraperWiki’s board | ScraperWiki Data Blog
Pingback: High-Performing Boards in Early Stage Biotech | Life Sci VC
Pingback: High Performing Boards in Early Stage Biotech - Forbes
Pingback: High Performing Boards in Early Stage Biotech | Tech Start Hub
Pingback: The Best and Worst Board Meetings | DELIBERATE FORESIGHT : .* SCENARIO PLANNING
Pingback: The Best and Worst Board Meetings | Deliberate Foresight
Pingback: My Favorite Board Meetings - Rand's Blog
Pingback: Finding Feld’s Finest Thoughts | Kevin Way
Pingback: xbox 360
Pingback: penisadvantage
Pingback: the truth about six pack abs review
Pingback: bumperstickerquotes.org
Pingback: penis advantage
Pingback: get edu backlinks
Pingback: hostgator discount code
Pingback: get a free ipad
Pingback: best 60 led tv
Pingback: backlink building service
Pingback: xbox 360 giveaway
Pingback: cheap portable dvd player
Pingback: truth about six pack abs review
Pingback: does penis advantage work
Pingback: penis advantage
Pingback: penisadvantage
Pingback: Stefany Lonneman
Pingback: Adolfo Imamura
Pingback: cheap edu backlinks
Pingback: hostgator coupon codes
Pingback: how to get a free ipad
Pingback: xbox 360 giveaway
Pingback: truth about abs review
Pingback: penis advantage
Pingback: Verlie Chism
Pingback: Jerrell Honokaupu
Pingback: Alexander Braver
Pingback: Alexander Braver
Pingback: Adrienne Sinning
Pingback: Pamella Hohensee
Pingback: Ayesha Obiesie
Pingback: Barbie Duffer
Pingback: Johnathan Gadwah
Pingback: Roland Creese
Pingback: Marcus Botdorf
Pingback: Lyla Diepenbrock
Pingback: Sal Moreida
Pingback: Leda Tepe
Pingback: tao of badass reviews
Pingback: tao of badass review
Pingback: Claretta Rusert
Pingback: Jerold Auter
Pingback: Marion Farley
Pingback: Jordon Sylney
Pingback: Beverley Waldrep
Pingback: Trenton Dewick
Pingback: Granville Stclaire
Pingback: Russell Fingleton
Pingback: Royal Guecho
Pingback: Tatiana Glory
Pingback: Thanh Slimmer
Pingback: Rosario Mavromatis
Pingback: Melida Heritage
Pingback: Ellis Yandell
Pingback: Edda Turbyfill
Pingback: Edmund Rolf
Pingback: Malika Spiers
Pingback: Rocky Gasquet
Pingback: Ardis Leonette
Pingback: Hunter Ruvo
Pingback: Shanae Sodhi
Pingback: Pat Swapp
Pingback: Erich Trodden
Pingback: Wilmer Cringle
Pingback: Erika Wilch
Pingback: Clotilde Acker
Pingback: Terry Vandamme
Pingback: Margarito Lizotte
Pingback: Mohammed Hnat
Pingback: Delana Friends
Pingback: Wendell Hourihan
Pingback: Nga Liszewski
Pingback: Jed Phyfiher
Pingback: Cameron Riedesel
Pingback: Karan Delgado
Pingback: Lonnie Lommel
Pingback: Tammi Razinger
Pingback: Xenia Bjornstrom
Pingback: Jenelle Tostanoski
Pingback: Jame Tefera
Pingback: Jame Tefera
Pingback: Katia Thibadeau
Pingback: Leroy Deodato
Pingback: Micah Mantanona
Pingback: Clement Devincent
Pingback: Douglas Henson
Pingback: Stanley Malave
Pingback: Yaeko Krakowsky
Pingback: Paul Haider
Pingback: Fausto Benford
Pingback: See Jackowski
Pingback: Ferdinand Rothmiller
Pingback: Kevin Granath
Pingback: Mira Trentini
Pingback: Mercedez Kochert
Pingback: Numbers Puma
Pingback: Avril Padron
Pingback: Scot Minish
Pingback: Lucius Gumina
Pingback: Sandy Holley
Pingback: Jamal Stoltz
Pingback: Jimmy Yerkes
Pingback: Chanelle Batto
Pingback: Jo Picton
Pingback: Quinn Corpening
Pingback: Jesse Scoh
Pingback: Daren Seminario
Pingback: Dalton Kodama
Pingback: Bette Tourigny
Pingback: Loura Vonbraunsberg
Pingback: George Racey
Pingback: Gayle Jereb
Pingback: Leigh Osorno
Pingback: Celena Wurdeman
Pingback: Winnifred Kirchmann
Pingback: Deandra Vonderheide
Pingback: Sol Yagues
Pingback: Freddie Nao
Pingback: Alex Prevot
Pingback: Minh Butel
Pingback: Shaquana Savich
Pingback: Rochell Rihner
Pingback: Breana Dugdale
Pingback: Gregory Chamul
Pingback: Miles Tomehak
Pingback: Jamison Mackellar
Pingback: Frankie Hadsell
Pingback: Mireya Croswell
Pingback: Josef Watring
Pingback: Yetta Savin
Pingback: Rey Mccreadie
Pingback: Mike Carmo
Pingback: Eulah Forsberg
Pingback: Kris Smarr
Pingback: Bernetta Grapes
Pingback: Alvaro Fann
Pingback: Eugenia Medel
Pingback: Karon Shroeder
Pingback: Lino Houchen
Pingback: Marlen Sommerfeld
Pingback: Jacques Krawetz
Pingback: Deborah Demara
Pingback: Dalila Dyal
Pingback: Carol Copping
Pingback: Pisanie prac magisterskich
Pingback: polskie strony www
Pingback: Andre Deller
Pingback: http://editorialmac.mx/groups/notasdehoy/wiki/d5fe3/Just_what_Every_one_Should_Understand_about_the_Truth_about_Six_Pack_Abs.html
Pingback: silver jewellery with amber
Pingback: http://server.jackson-williams.com/groups/jwa/wiki/90458/Just_what_exactly_All_and_sundry_Has_to_Learn_about_the_Truth_about_Six_Pack_Abs.html
Pingback: Pablo Mcclair
Pingback: Fredric Valois
Pingback: Lucio Todora
Pingback: Waylon Lamango
Pingback: Jammie Natsis
Pingback: Chi Harnar
Pingback: Benito Guariglia
Pingback: Ray Mayr
Pingback: Eve Petross
Pingback: Raphael Schweiner
Pingback: Keven Natalizio
Pingback: how to home brew beer
Pingback: Demetrice Oms
Pingback: Gerardo Goulbourne
Pingback: can you buy generic duloxetine over the counter
Pingback: Lizeth Puletasi
Pingback: Dannie Mainor
Pingback: Norbert Ahuja
Pingback: Herb Taddonio
Pingback: Finding Good Pizza in Las Vegas
Pingback: Georgiann Terwilliger
Pingback: Tasha Froschheiser
Pingback: Kerrie Feduccia
Pingback: Val Sunde
Pingback: Edmond Bois
Pingback: pozycjonowanie kraków
Pingback: Adriane Brazzel
Pingback: distilling equipment
Pingback: tanie hotele w paryżu
Pingback: Kurtis Cokeley
Pingback: hotele w paryżu
Pingback: Winford Neary
Pingback: Gilberto Barranger
Pingback: Kathern Chafe
Pingback: Colin Smyntek
Pingback: Abe Hooker
Pingback: zdrowy dom
Pingback: Marlon Ekins
Pingback: Kennith Kalil
Pingback: blog website
Pingback: Corina Tuff
Pingback: Xochitl Lindberg
Pingback: My Blog
Pingback: Ivory Angelone
Pingback: Bernie Mastriano
Pingback: Roscoe Kuchar
Pingback: clothing
Pingback: Ami Wolner
Pingback: Jordan Saulter
Pingback: Na Sonza
Pingback: Trey Bubolz
Pingback: Tracey Campanella
Pingback: Lia Rackett
Pingback: link building agency
Pingback: best gaming computer 2013
Pingback: Tuyet Demere
Pingback: flashlights
Pingback: Leroy Dantes
Pingback: Darron Mcgloster
Pingback: reign dark cyde
Pingback: Lelah Shelkoff
Pingback: ziana gel
Pingback: photo
Pingback: Avril Ahhee
Pingback: website
Pingback: Laurence Meisenheimer
Pingback: Darrel Mckim
Pingback: Billie Scouten
Pingback: Secured loans
Pingback: Lashanda Moradel
Pingback: Tanya Edenholm
Pingback: hypnosis
Pingback: Malcom Hurston
Pingback: industrial LCD display
Pingback: buy viagra
Pingback: Leigh Abrantes
Pingback: brazolot migration group
Pingback: escort london
Pingback: plumbers swansea
Pingback: Rhodos
Pingback: push present
Pingback: leviev
Pingback: oblique interiors site
Pingback: College Job
Pingback: http://www.911paydayloans.co.uk/
Pingback: العاب المزرعه
Pingback: toledo bend cabin rentals
Pingback: roulette ace
Pingback: Google
Pingback: Florist In Thurrock
Pingback: buy houses cash desoto texas 469-248-6544
Pingback: click the next internet site
Pingback: how to do it yourself
Pingback: Write your Autobiography
Pingback: augen laser
Pingback: outlet oakley miami
Pingback: Video
Pingback: tea for weight loss
Pingback: Tablets
Pingback: IT Consulting
Pingback: new england wedding bands
Pingback: Edwin Tarry
Pingback: Money Choice Matt George
Pingback: Jade Andreoli
Pingback: Lashandra Mathiasen
Pingback: Send bulk emails
Pingback: Mirta Decaneo
Pingback: Bernardo Alpheaus
Pingback: buy twitter retweets
Pingback: homeopathic
Pingback: yournetbiz scam
Pingback: Milda Betts
Pingback: slatwall displays
Pingback: Valery Mandley
Pingback: Get Him Back Forever
Pingback: Lenard Arbertha
Pingback: fort worth bankruptcy attorney
Pingback: indoor trampoline
Pingback: become webcam model
Pingback: Jim Mosconi
Pingback: Lakia Wykle
Pingback: motorcycle carrier
Pingback: here
Pingback: Rosendo Debey
Pingback: money-lender-singapore.html
Pingback: Wrinkle Cream
Pingback: Vick Strizheus Big Idea Mastermind Creator Teacher