I read a fascinating book yesterday called *The Lights in the Tunnel: Automation, Accelerating Technology and the Economy of the Future* by Martin Ford. I can’t remember who sent it to me (someone did – thank you); it appeared on the of my infinite pile of books so I gobbled it down as my first book at 2010.

The first half of the book sets up the situation and the corresponding problems. I agreed with much of the first half. The second half proposes a solution. I had a hugely difficult time with it. Ford anticipated this as he regularly acknowledged (unnecessarily) throughout the second half that many people would have a hard time with his proposed solution. Yet he marched on relentlessly.

Ford’s basic premise is as follows:

“

At some point in the future – it might be many years or decades from now – machines will be able to do the jobs of a large percentage of the ‘average’ people in our population, and these people willnotbe able to find new jobs.”

Ford does a good job of spending the first half of this book making the case for this. He draws nicely from the notion of a technological singularity (which many of us are now calling simple “the singularity” for convenience), explains why mainstream economists (and the notion of econometrics in general) are basically historians rather than effective predictors of the future, does a nice job weaving the Luddite Fallacy into the mix, makes a compelling argument about China’s role in this he calls the “China Fallacy”, and wraps it up by revisiting a variety of conventional views of the future while asking “do we really believe they are going to play out this way?” (answer = no).

At this point I took a break and went for a walk around the block with my dogs. I knew the book was shifting from “problem” to “solution” (the next chapter was titled *Transition*) and I wanted to clear my mind so I could absorb it. I had a couple of weak ideas about where Ford was going to go, but it was pretty fuzzy to me. So I dove back in.

The second half of the book blew me away. Ford starts by asserting underlying his mental model – that in the future 75% unemployment will permanently exist because jobs will have been automated away – and they will not be replaceable. So – the vast majority of people in our society will be “unemployable” in a conventional sense (as in a 40 hour / week job). Ford asks rhetorically “Is it possible to have a prosperous economy and a civil society in such a scenario?” (answer = yes and he’s going to propose a way to do it.)

The base on which he builds his solution is the following idea:

“We will have to undergo a quantum shift in our value system. In order to preserve the free market system, we will have to come to the realization that while work (at least for most people) may no longer be essential,broad-based consumption is essential.”

He then spends the balance of the book explaining a government-driven taxation and incentive approach that taxes companies based on their permanently lost wages (based on automation, which he asserts will increase gross margins) while incenting the unemployed to act in ways that benefit themselves and societies by paying them based on how they act and contribute in this “non-traditional job” way. Ford suggests several simple categories, including Education (self and others), Community and Civic Activities, Journalism, and the Environment. He then spends a lot of time explaining the implementation at a high level, including an abstract example of how a functioning free-market society could exist post the singularity.

Sometime during reading this stuff my brain exploded and I had to go take the dogs for another walk. When I came back, I tried to explain this to Amy but couldn’t. I tried to make the argument that all government employees (local, state, and federal) are already in this category so the jump from the federally reported 10% unemployment to 75% isn’t as big as we might think since 8% already work for the government (so let’s say the jump is from 20% to 75%). I couldn’t do it – I just couldn’t take myself seriously.

While I love Ford’s tenacity with the idea and radical approach, I think this book would have worked better as science fiction rather than an attempt at an economic / political essay. Ironically, I might have been able to buy the argument better in the context of science fiction; when put against the backdrop of our existing social / societal construct, it was too difficult for me to absorb.

I have a belief that the structure of what we call “modern society” will have to change post singularity. I don’t yet have my own hypothesis for what this looks like, but many of my favorite science fiction writers have been hacking away at this for several decades. And I’m continuing to slurp down as much stuff as I can about the singularity since I both (a) believe it will happen in my lifetime – assuming I live a normal life expectancy and (b) I hope I’ll be involved in helping create it.

I’ll be following Ford’s blogging at his site *econfuture: Future Economics and Technology**. *Even though I struggled with his solution, it’s another interesting input for me to ponder. And all of this also led me (via an article titled *Martin Ford Asks: Will Automation Lead to Economic Collapse?*) to a fun new website called *Singularity Hub *which has now been added to my feedreader. Now, time for some more Philip K. Dick.

Pingback: Tweets that mention The Lights in the Tunnel -- Topsy.com()

Pingback: Singularity | Sramana Mitra on Strategy()

Pingback: Brad Feld Reviews The Lights in the Tunnel « econfuture | Future Economics and Technology()

Pingback: Weekend reading: Whither the GOP, after the world gets eaten, and science reading and writing « Frank Hecker()

Pingback: xbox 360()

Pingback: penis advantage reviews()

Pingback: truth about six pack abs review()

Pingback: Ha Treusdell()

Pingback: penis advantage reviews()

Pingback: cheap edu backlinks()

Pingback: hostgator reviews()

Pingback: free ipads()

Pingback: led televisions()

Pingback: buy quality backlinks()

Pingback: xbox giveaway()

Pingback: best portable dvd player for car()

Pingback: the truth about six pack abs review()

Pingback: truth about abs review()

Pingback: penis advantage review()

Pingback: penis advantage scam()

Pingback: penis advantage scam()

Pingback: Landon Mockler()

Pingback: Antonio Lafrance()

Pingback: Deadra Baniaga()

Pingback: Treasa Bethell()

Pingback: edu backlink service()

Pingback: free ipad()

Pingback: best led tv deals()

Pingback: backlinks service()

Pingback: xbox 360 giveaway()

Pingback: the truth about abs()

Pingback: does penis advantage work()

Pingback: Bernie Northington()

Pingback: Deshawn Steenberg()

Pingback: Alexander Braver()

Pingback: Trinity Orea()

Pingback: Zachariah Brean()

Pingback: Kareem Henton()

Pingback: Stephen Degrandpre()

Pingback: Barbie Duffer()

Pingback: Walton Campoli()

Pingback: Marcus Botdorf()

Pingback: Hiroko Prestidge()

Pingback: Roland Creese()

Pingback: Demetrius Sweatman()

Pingback: Noel Demman()

Pingback: Thanh Slimmer()

Pingback: tao of badass()

Pingback: Muriel Liversedge()

Pingback: Jonathon Volden()

Pingback: Sophia Kufner()

Pingback: Jada Bernd()

Pingback: Benito Schlag()

Pingback: Rico Bethel()

Pingback: Sal Moreida()

Pingback: Keith Conigliaro()

Pingback: Georgette Rebolledo()

Pingback: Lawanna Schreuder()

Pingback: Renato Whittie()

Pingback: Eloy Selking()

Pingback: Edmund Rolf()

Pingback: Rayford Crease()

Pingback: Louie Joerger()

Pingback: Graig Hedin()

Pingback: Dallas Mana()

Pingback: Silas Tomka()

Pingback: Pat Swapp()

Pingback: Cruz Kohnert()

Pingback: Dominique Mikelsen()

Pingback: Nikki Konger()

Pingback: Margarito Lizotte()

Pingback: Felecia Kolkman()

Pingback: Leonardo Kavadias()

Pingback: Titus Somdah()

Pingback: Dorsey Manago()

Pingback: Larhonda Laventure()

Pingback: Lorenzo Potulski()

Pingback: Charise Dasgupta()

Pingback: Taisha Jolissaint()

Pingback: Virgil Lhuillier()

Pingback: Roseanna Venner()

Pingback: Pasquale Majuste()

Pingback: Jenelle Tostanoski()

Pingback: Clotilde Watzke()

Pingback: www.bumperstickerquotes.org()

Pingback: Take pleasure()

Pingback: Ashton Bartle()

Pingback: Dominick Galardo()

Pingback: Taunya Sarantakis()

Pingback: Johnathon Malgieri()

Pingback: Gavin Fillinger()

Pingback: Issac Spruill()

Pingback: Victoria Mesch()

Pingback: Opal Arlington()

Pingback: Kris Metevier()

Pingback: Miles Falsetti()

Pingback: Anton Fermo()

Pingback: Val Zody()

Pingback: Marvin Prather()

Pingback: Karrie Fasci()

Pingback: Setsuko Subler()

Pingback: Gilma Cogley()

Pingback: Gretchen Torello()

Pingback: Kermit Belser()

Pingback: Sherwood Donoho()

Pingback: Gayle Jereb()

Pingback: Man Aldrich()

Pingback: Glen Fitzen()

Pingback: Michel Larabell()

Pingback: Fern Ghazal()

Pingback: Taren Varady()

Pingback: Woodrow Bunda()

Pingback: Clinton Debutts()

Pingback: Lyndsey Knudsvig()

Pingback: Wilbur Visalli()

Pingback: Alona Wnukowski()

Pingback: Alec Batliner()

Pingback: Jerrod Teakell()

Pingback: Dean Pounder()

Pingback: Issac Hilu()

Pingback: Armando Gschwend()

Pingback: Moses Ehn()

Pingback: Tequila Gunderman()

Pingback: Verdell Ronne()

Pingback: Xavier Casparian()

Pingback: Bella Callabrass()

Pingback: Ned Salierno()

Pingback: Karin Preuitt()

Pingback: Wendell Leben()

Pingback: Jerrold Gritton()

Pingback: Jan Antigua()

Pingback: Lara Hass()

Pingback: http://hoiberghosting.macminicolo.net/groups/mediashout/wiki/c3ec8/Just_what_Every_one_Must_Find_out_about_the_Truth_about_Six_Pack_Abs.html()

Pingback: http://wiki.waltheracademy.net/groups/welcometomrssmithsclass2010/wiki/295f4/What_All_and_sundry_Has_to_Understand_about_the_Truth_about_Six_Pack_Abs.html()

Pingback: Cliff Atchinson()

Pingback: http://75.145.137.121/groups/paper/wiki/f3a3b/Unlock_your_extraordinary_tunes_expertise_using_the_highest_quality_conquer_creating_software_application.html()

Pingback: Shonta Dante()

Pingback: Pat Epler()

Pingback: Delmar Eisensmith()

Pingback: Norbert Feger()

Pingback: Marcelene Gautam()

Pingback: Jonnie Fudge()

Pingback: Kaley Groeschel()

Pingback: Salvatore Deveny()

Pingback: Maryetta Sifre()

Pingback: Eve Petross()

Pingback: Hayden Salzl()

Pingback: Wendie Delavergne()

Pingback: Quentin Beilstein()

Pingback: Deon Kraling()

Pingback: Eneida Velthuis()

Pingback: Audra Larribeau()

Pingback: Tommie Mctee()

Pingback: Dannie Mainor()

Pingback: Starr Skipworth()

Pingback: Rocco Toscano()

Pingback: Alice Gaser()

Pingback: Darin Mirarchi()

Pingback: Xochitl Sabado()

Pingback: Wesley Gagon()

Pingback: Gail Medak()

Pingback: Adolph Birckbichler()

Pingback: Carter Grasse()

Pingback: Clair Kehler()

Pingback: Mervin Milliren()

Pingback: Booker Kleinberg()

Pingback: Thomasena Haberstroh()

Pingback: Fay Mcbrien()

Pingback: Bert Sonkin()

Pingback: Sterling Fuentes()

Pingback: Valarie Jumonville()

Pingback: Keven Kolber()

Pingback: Harland Berdugo()

Pingback: Robbie Vollmar()

Pingback: Everett Fracasso()

Pingback: Jordan Saulter()

Pingback: Nereida Akery()

Pingback: Keila Trelles()

Pingback: Miriam Sberna()

Pingback: Robby Martineze()

Pingback: Darrick Tucek()

Pingback: Moon Luetmer()

Pingback: Kristian Torreson()

Pingback: Ernest Kuboushek()

Pingback: Melva Dejongh()

Pingback: Yer Curney()

Pingback: Christeen Salazan()

Pingback: Vernon Norse()

Pingback: Kyle Noyola()

Pingback: Demarcus Tohonnie()

Pingback: Billie Lumbra()

Pingback: Albert Dado()

Pingback: Tanya Edenholm()

Pingback: Shelia Gleitz()

Pingback: Lyda Daigh()

Pingback: Kendall Delacuesta()

Pingback: Milagro Dagnese()

Pingback: Pamula Ruedas()

Pingback: Willette Bussey()

Pingback: Todd Minneweather()

Pingback: Tessa Burgh()

Pingback: Lakia Wykle()

Pingback: Elizbeth Sydnes()